World

Why the U.S.–Israel Strategy to Topple Iran Has Failed?

Professor John Mearsheimer, one of the most influential political scientists of our time and the leading voice of structural realism in international relations, has delivered a stark critique of U.S. and Israeli policy toward Iran. In his view, the recent unrest in Iran is not a spontaneous democratic uprising, but the latest chapter in a familiar and deliberate regime-change playbook, one that has failed to achieve its ultimate goal.

According to Mearsheimer, the West’s narrative of a popular revolt against misgovernance conceals a far more calculated strategy. He identifies a four-part approach used by the United States and Israel to try to dismantle the Iranian regime, drawing parallels to previous interventions in countries like Iraq, Syria, and Libya. But this time, he argues, the strategy has collapsed under the weight of its own contradictions and Iran’s resilience.

The first phase is economic warfare. The United States imposed waves of crushing sanctions intended not merely to pressure the Iranian government, but to create widespread suffering across Iranian society. The idea, Mearsheimer suggests, is that severe economic pain will lead to public anger, unrest, and eventually, protest movements that weaken the regime from within.

Next comes the fueling of protests. Western media portrays these protests as purely organic and democratic, but Mearsheimer claims that outside actors actively support and amplify them. He cites reports of U.S. and Israeli involvement, including Israeli media sources, statements from Western officials, and the covert provision of Starlink internet terminals to demonstrators once the Iranian government shut down online access, as evidence that unrest is being coordinated and empowered from abroad.

The third phase is a disinformation campaign, one tailored to two distinct audiences. Inside Iran, messaging is designed to convince the public that the regime is collapsing and that its fall is inevitable. Meanwhile, outside Iran, Western media frames the events as a courageous democratic uprising, ignoring the structural role of sanctions and foreign support. According to Mearsheimer, this dual narrative helps isolate the regime diplomatically and undermines its legitimacy both at home and abroad.

Finally, the fourth phase involves military intervention, which is often kept in reserve but prepared in case the regime appears close to collapse. The strategy here, he argues, is to deliver a final blow, targeting infrastructure, leadership networks, and critical facilities, once internal dissent has sufficiently weakened the state. While this has not yet occurred in Iran, Mearsheimer warns that military action remains a live possibility, especially under U.S. administrations seeking quick results.

However, he concludes that this four-part strategy has failed. The protests that briefly flared in Iran have sharply declined. The Iranian government’s internal crackdown has been brutal but effective. Even Israeli analysts and former President Donald Trump’s changing rhetoric, Mearsheimer notes, reflect a recognition that the regime-change gamble has not paid off.

What concerns him now is the risk of escalation. He suggests that Trump, having initially believed the Iranian regime was on the verge of collapse, may resort to force to “salvage” a failing policy. Yet, the United States no longer enjoys the regional military dominance it once had. Iran, for its part, has made clear that any military strike, by the U.S. or Israel, would be met with direct retaliation. The stakes are vastly higher in today’s multipolar world, and a misstep could ignite a broader regional conflict.

Mearsheimer’s analysis stands out because it challenges widely accepted assumptions and exposes the deeper logic of international power politics. He warns that what might appear to be a democratic uprising may in fact be a carefully orchestrated campaign, a point that should caution observers against accepting simplified media narratives at face value. He argues that economic interdependence, far from preventing conflict, has now become a tool of strategic leverage, seen most clearly in Iran and also in U.S., China tensions over rare earth materials.

In this light, the Iran case offers a sobering example of how realist dynamics continue to shape global affairs. Mearsheimer’s structural realism emphasizes the enduring influence of great-power rivalry, the limits of moralistic foreign policy, and the high risks of strategic miscalculation. The attempt to dismantle Iran’s regime through sanctions, protest engineering, narrative warfare, and the looming threat of force, he believes, is not just failing; it may be dangerously backfiring

Disclaimer

https://thevoice.pk/disclaimer/

Back to top button